| Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? | |
|
+3commandersasha DominicJ Mushkilla 7 posters |
Author | Message |
---|
Mushkilla Arena Champion
Posts : 4017 Join date : 2012-07-16 Location : Toroid Arena
| Subject: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Wed Apr 10 2013, 19:59 | |
| The rules for monstrous creature say: - Quote :
- Monstrous Creatures can fire up to two of their weapons each shooting phase - BRB page 48
I take it that means a talos with splinter cannons and a liquifier can only fire one or the other during overwatch. Am I correct? Or did I miss something. | |
|
| |
DominicJ Wych
Posts : 662 Join date : 2013-01-23
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Wed Apr 10 2013, 20:21 | |
| It doesnt say anything about overwatch? | |
|
| |
commandersasha Sybarite
Posts : 414 Join date : 2012-12-26 Location : Wimbledon, London
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Wed Apr 10 2013, 21:57 | |
| The wording is "An Overwatch attack is resolved like a normal shooting attack..." BRBp21"...and uses all the normal rules for range,...and so on". A multi-model infantry unit's shooting attack can contain multiple shots, of different weapons, therefore so can an MC's.
I can see the query, but I'd say I fall into the 2 guns in Overwatch camp. If you charged my Dakkafex, I'd expect to shoot 12 shots at you! | |
|
| |
Dogmar Sybarite
Posts : 397 Join date : 2011-11-22 Location : Germany
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Wed Apr 10 2013, 22:24 | |
| I agree with commandersasha, his quote is spot on. Therefore the talos would be able to overwatch with the Liquifier and the second weapon (cannon, HWB, HL). | |
|
| |
Mushkilla Arena Champion
Posts : 4017 Join date : 2012-07-16 Location : Toroid Arena
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Thu Apr 11 2013, 07:02 | |
| Agreed, but this argument has come up in my store. And I'm sure it will come up even more with the wording of Tau multi trackers being the same. Those suits can only overwatch with one weapon! etc etc...
Sigh, for the love of the muses playtest! Or at least react to the FAQ emails GW! | |
|
| |
commandersasha Sybarite
Posts : 414 Join date : 2012-12-26 Location : Wimbledon, London
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Thu Apr 11 2013, 10:04 | |
| ...or have the game designers and Official Rules Publishers on a forum! | |
|
| |
Shadows Revenge Hierarch of Tactica
Posts : 2587 Join date : 2011-08-10 Location : Bmore
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Thu Apr 11 2013, 15:56 | |
| yah I would agree that suits and other things that can shoot two weapons (like MCs) can fire both. Overwatch uses all shooting rules, and even says treat it as a shoot phase. So multiple shots here we go!!!
Its not playtesting... its laziness. They copied and pasted it from last edition where there was only 1 shooting phase and nothing else. Plus remember in GW land everyone uses common sense and there is never a difference in oppinions or interpretations | |
|
| |
Count Adhemar Dark Lord of Granbretan
Posts : 7610 Join date : 2012-04-26 Location : London
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Thu Apr 11 2013, 16:01 | |
| - Shadows Revenge wrote:
- Its not playtesting... its laziness. They copied and pasted it from last edition where there was only 1 shooting phase and nothing else. Plus remember in GW land everyone uses common sense and there is never a difference in oppinions or interpretations
And if there is, they just roll a dice for it. Saves having to write decent rules! | |
|
| |
Evil Space Elves Haemonculus Ancient
Posts : 3717 Join date : 2011-07-13 Location : Santa Cruz, ca
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Thu Apr 11 2013, 16:24 | |
| - Mushkilla wrote:
- Agreed, but this argument has come up in my store.
Sigh, for the love of the muses playtest! Or at least react to the FAQ emails GW! Or, tell the rules lawyers to shove it! I agree with the consensus here= 2 weapons.(Of course, I do play Tau... ) | |
|
| |
Mushkilla Arena Champion
Posts : 4017 Join date : 2012-07-16 Location : Toroid Arena
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Thu Apr 11 2013, 16:46 | |
| - Evil Space Elves wrote:
- Of course, I do play Tau...
What treachery is this? | |
|
| |
Evil Space Elves Haemonculus Ancient
Posts : 3717 Join date : 2011-07-13 Location : Santa Cruz, ca
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Thu Apr 11 2013, 17:13 | |
| - Mushkilla wrote:
- Evil Space Elves wrote:
- Of course, I do play Tau...
What treachery is this? Traded and old Dwarf army for a Tau one a few years back. I play 6 different 40k armies...I've been at this for a while Dark Eldar are my babies though! | |
|
| |
Mushkilla Arena Champion
Posts : 4017 Join date : 2012-07-16 Location : Toroid Arena
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Thu Apr 11 2013, 17:37 | |
| To be fair I have 2k of tau in a box somewhere including a forge world baracuda I managed to buy for $10! But in that box they will stay. | |
|
| |
commandersasha Sybarite
Posts : 414 Join date : 2012-12-26 Location : Wimbledon, London
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? Fri Apr 12 2013, 00:30 | |
| - Evil Space Elves wrote:
- ...Dark Eldar are my babies though!
I bet you say that to all the forums...! | |
|
| |
Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? | |
| |
|
| |
| Monstours Creatures can only overwatch with one weapon!? | |
|