| Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? | |
|
+3Bibitybopitybacon Dark_Kindred The Shredder 7 posters |
Author | Message |
---|
The Shredder Trueborn
Posts : 2970 Join date : 2013-04-11
| Subject: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Mon Jul 15 2013, 22:44 | |
| Just used this list recently:
Baron Sathonyx
3 Trueborn - 3x Blasters; Venom - Splinter Cannon
5 Warriors - Blaster; Venom - Splinter Cannon 5 Warriors - Blaster; Venom - Splinter Cannon
9 Hellions
Ravager - 3x Dark Lance
750pts exactly
One of my opponents seemed very displeased with me using 4 vehicles at 750 (it was a 2v2 and each other player had just one vehicle). However, considering how fragile DE are, it feels like I have little choice.
So, am I'm being harsh by using 4 vehicles at 750pts? | |
|
| |
Dark_Kindred Kabalite Warrior
Posts : 207 Join date : 2012-12-30
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 00:34 | |
| No. I bring 3 at 500 and that could be construed as "less than optimal." You're doing him a favor by bringing Hellions. You could have done something like this:
Haemonculus
5 Kabalite Warriors with Blaster in Venom w/ Dual Splinter Cannons 5 Kabalite Warriors with Blaster in Venom w/ Dual Splinter Cannons 5 Kabalite Warriors with Blaster in Raider w/ Dark Lance or Disintegrater Cannon 5 Kabalite Warriors with Blaster in Raider w/ Dark Lance or Disintegrater Cannon
Ravager Ravager
That has 2(4) more lances, 1 more Troop, two more vehicles, and can target more vehicle and infantry units during the shooting phase.
To reiterate: No, you're not being harsh. The army is clearly designed to be mechanized. Even then, STR 4 weapons are a threat so your opponents should just accept that. | |
|
| |
Bibitybopitybacon Wych
Posts : 592 Join date : 2012-07-01
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 03:38 | |
| Yeah... what dark kindred said. With the death of the webway portal list 4 vehicles at 750 is very conservative for any de list. You. Would always go with three talos and a couple wrack blobs with liquifier guns hoofing it but that would probably tick him off more. Lol | |
|
| |
Vasara Incognito assault marine
Posts : 1160 Join date : 2012-08-22 Location : Vantaa
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 08:31 | |
| Too many vehicles in a DE list? Never. Compare your to Dark_Kindreds list and notice that yours wasn't that over the top at all. And besides opponents who start to shoot uor vehicles always become happy because they are so easy to explode. And you should change trueborns to another Kabalite squad in your own list. | |
|
| |
Ben_S Sybarite
Posts : 376 Join date : 2012-05-20 Location : Stirling, Scotland
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 10:49 | |
| I don't think that's too many at all.
Bringing a lot of high AV tanks may skew balance, if your opponents aren't geared for it, but since our vehicles can be shot down by bolters (as already pointed out) it shouldn't be something that your opponent is unequipped to deal with. | |
|
| |
The Shredder Trueborn
Posts : 2970 Join date : 2013-04-11
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 11:18 | |
| Thanks for the replies, everyone. 4 vehicles didn't seem too bad to me - especially considering the low AV and hull points on 3 of them. But then, my opponent really hates Splinter Cannons on venoms and thinks they're incredibly unfair. - Vasara wrote:
And besides opponents who start to shoot uor vehicles always become happy because they are so easy to explode. The person who constantly complained about them actually destroyed one of my venoms on the first turn with ~7 bolter shots, despite it having 3+ cover (behind ruins and night fight). He still moaned throughout the entire game about how unfair they are. - Vasara wrote:
- And you should change trueborns to another Kabalite squad in your own list.
Can I ask why? My concern is that, if the Ravager dies, I'd have very little anti-vehicle. Relying on single blasters in warrior squads seems a bit dicey. | |
|
| |
DominicJ Wych
Posts : 662 Join date : 2013-01-23
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 13:03 | |
| Not even a little bit. Its not like you took three demolishers, | |
|
| |
Dark_Kindred Kabalite Warrior
Posts : 207 Join date : 2012-12-30
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 17:03 | |
| - The Shredder wrote:
- Thanks for the replies, everyone.
4 vehicles didn't seem too bad to me - especially considering the low AV and hull points on 3 of them. But then, my opponent really hates Splinter Cannons on venoms and thinks they're incredibly unfair.
Ah, the "It's unfair because I don't have/understand it" argument. Maybe you should do some math for him. A Venom should kill 1.33 Marines on average, 2 Fire Warriors, or 4 Guardsmen [no cover]. Running the numbers against a Boltgun, 12 Boltgun shots will kill 2.66 Fire Warriors and 5.33 Guardsmen [no cover] in addition to being able to hurt vehicles. If your opponent is still miffed about Venoms, you could get your local Mechanized Craftworld Eldar friend to take something like this: Farseer 100 10 Guardian Defenders in Wave Serpent w/ Bright Lance 210 10 Guardian Defenders in Wave Serpent w/ Bright Lance & Shuriken Cannon 220 10 Guardian Defenders in Wave Serpent w/ Bright Lance & Shuriken Cannon 220 Clearly, there are bigger problems than a halfhearted Venom Spam.
Last edited by Dark_Kindred on Tue Jul 16 2013, 18:53; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : and is NOT or) | |
|
| |
Evil Space Elves Haemonculus Ancient
Posts : 3717 Join date : 2011-07-13 Location : Santa Cruz, ca
| |
| |
The Shredder Trueborn
Posts : 2970 Join date : 2013-04-11
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 18:51 | |
| - Evil Space Elves wrote:
- I'm going out on a limb here, but I'm guessing that this opponent moans and whines a lot?
Oh my yes. Anything and everything that damages his army in the slightest is unbalanced. Also, if he loses, it is only ever because the dice screwed him over. Tactical mistakes or bad army lists do not factor into it. | |
|
| |
Dark_Kindred Kabalite Warrior
Posts : 207 Join date : 2012-12-30
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 19:03 | |
| - The Shredder wrote:
- Evil Space Elves wrote:
- I'm going out on a limb here, but I'm guessing that this opponent moans and whines a lot?
Oh my yes.
Anything and everything that damages his army in the slightest is unbalanced.
Also, if he loses, it is only ever because the dice screwed him over. Tactical mistakes or bad army lists do not factor into it. That raises several questions. 1. Why did you even ask if your army was harsh if this person is a whiny tool? 2. What does such a player do when losing against a similar army? 3. What about the other opponent? You implied that he also looked annoyed. 4. Did you win? 5. Other questions. | |
|
| |
The Shredder Trueborn
Posts : 2970 Join date : 2013-04-11
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? Tue Jul 16 2013, 22:27 | |
| - Dark_Kindred wrote:
- That raises several questions.
1. Why did you even ask if your army was harsh if this person is a whiny tool? 2. What does such a player do when losing against a similar army? 3. What about the other opponent? You implied that he also looked annoyed. 4. Did you win? 5. Other questions. 1) Well, the fact that he complains about a lot of things doesn't necessarily mean that all his complaints are invalid. Considering that every other player brought just one vehicle, I wondered if he had a point. In any case, it wasn't something I'd really considered and thought it was an interesting question. 2) Do you mean a similar army to his own? As far as I can recall, we haven't had such a matchup. For the most part, we all have different armies, so we rarely face our own army. 3) If I implied that, then it was unintentional. He didn't complain about anything and accepted his losses with good grace. 4) Yes - we annihilated them on turn 5, having taken relatively few losses ourselves (I'd lost the baron's squad but not the baron, the ravager and a venom; my ally had lost several CSMs, and taken a wound on his lord, and that was about it.). | |
|
| |
Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? | |
| |
|
| |
| Is this too many vehicles for 750pts? | |
|